During EMDR history taking, we're learning about our client's current symptoms and the experiences that may be contributing to them. As clients describe what's been happening, you may notice that similar negative beliefs come up in different situations. For example, “It's my fault” might come up around an argument with a partner, a difficult interaction at work, and several childhood memories.
One of the questions that comes up in consultation is how to use that information in treatment planning. Negative cognitions in EMDR can help us explore connections among these experiences and identify possible targets. During history taking, we're beginning to understand those patterns with our clients and how they relate to the problems they've come in to address.
So let's look at what you can do with that information. We'll walk through how to recognize a repeated belief, identify experiences that seem to reinforce it, and use the cognition during floatback. Then we'll look at how those potential targets fit into the sequencing plan, as identifying the memories and deciding where to begin are separate decisions.
What Are You Trying to Clarify During History Taking?
Where you go next will depend on what you're trying to understand with your client. Sometimes you're still identifying targets, and sometimes you already have several memories but aren't sure how to organize them:
If the same belief appears around several situations → Explore what the belief means in each situation and whether the associated experiences appear related.
If a current trigger activates a belief and body sensation → Consider whether floatback can help identify earlier associated experiences, given your client's preparation and ability to remain present.
If you've identified several possible targets → Review their relationship to current symptoms and treatment goals before deciding on processing order.
If identifying the cognition has become frustrating → Consider whether your client's affective or somatic experience offers a clearer starting point (i.e. affect scan).
You may move between these questions as you learn more about your client. You can gather enough information to identify possible targets, then return to the specifics once your client has had more preparation.
What Can Negative Cognitions Tell You in EMDR History Taking?
During Phase 1, we're learning about our client's current problems and the experiences that may be contributing to them. As you gather the history, listen for how your client describes themselves. A statement such as “Everything's my fault” can give you a place to begin asking about earlier experiences and identifying possible targets (Shapiro, 2018).
For example, your client might describe being blamed for a parent's anger. You can ask what they came to believe about themselves through those experiences. If they say, “It's my fault,” you’d want to know when else they've felt that way and which experiences seem to reinforce that belief. You're beginning to understand how the belief developed and where it shows up in their life now.
Let's say your client also gets very upset when their boss seems irritated, has trouble setting boundaries with their partner, and feels responsible whenever someone is unhappy. You can explore whether “It's my fault” comes up in those situations too. Ask your client how the experiences feel connected, and note the memories that may belong together in the treatment plan.
At this point, you're gathering information and identifying possible targets. You can keep the history fairly general when needed and return to more detail as your client becomes prepared for the later phases of EMDR therapy. The repeated belief helps guide your questions, while your client's symptoms, goals, and history help you decide what to explore.
When the Same Negative Belief Appears Across Memories
When clients have a more complicated history, a repeated negative belief can help you find a place to start. You may have several experiences that look quite different on the surface, but your client feels the same way about themselves when they think about each one.
For example, “I am powerless” might come up around being unable to escape an abusive situation and around being afraid to tell a partner what they want. Ask your client what that belief means in each experience. Then notice the emotions and physical sensations that come with it, and how it relates to the problem they want help with now.
Look for related meanings within belief domains
Something to keep an eye on is whether the negative beliefs are in the same domain. “I should have stopped it” and “It's my fault” may both be about responsibility. A belief such as “I can't protect myself” might be more about safety or choice and control. You'll want to ask your client what it means for them.
If a client says, “Everything's my fault,” you might ask, “What would it mean about you if everything were your fault?” they might say, “I'm bad,” or “There's something wrong with me.” Now we may be moving from responsibility into defectiveness. Discuss that with your client and see whether you need to look at both themes or whether one fits their experience better.
The words themselves don't have to be identical for the beliefs to be related. At the same time, I wouldn't group memories together just because your client uses “I am bad” for each one. Ask what happened and what feels bad about them in that memory, so you can understand whether you're looking at the same theme.
Identify experiences that seem to reinforce the belief
The Two Method Approach by de Jongh and colleagues gives us two ways to identify targets. One starts with symptoms and the experiences associated with when they began or became worse. The other starts with a core belief and identifies experiences your client feels support that belief (de Jongh et al., 2010).
So if your client says, “I am unlovable,” you can ask which experiences seem to prove that to them. They may describe being excluded at school, being rejected in a relationship, or experiences with a caregiver. You can then write those down and review how they relate to what your client is struggling with.
Your focus is on asking what makes the belief feel true to your client. As they identify those experiences, note their age, what happened, and how disturbing the memory feels now. You may find that one experience feels like stronger evidence than another, even if it wasn't the earliest event or the one you'd expected them to choose.
Using a Negative Cognition During Floatback
I generally like using floatback because the negative cognition can help us connect the current problem with earlier experiences. Start with the most recent time your client felt that way, or an experience that represents the problem. Ask about the image, the negative belief, and what they notice in their body (Shapiro, 2018).
Let's use the example of a client who gets very upset when their boss seems irritated. You might ask, “Bring your mind to the most recent time you felt that way. What image represents the worst part?” They describe the look on the boss's face. You ask what negative belief comes up about them, and they say, “I am bad.” They also notice tension in their chest and stomach.
From there, you can invite them to hold the image and the words “I am bad,” notice the tension, and let their mind trace back to an earlier time they felt that way. A memory with a parent may come up, or they may recall something else entirely. Let your client tell you what comes to mind. A memory identified this way still needs to be assessed; the association doesn't establish historical accuracy or tell us which target to process first.
I tend to use the phrase“trace back” instead of “floatback” with clients because that wording minimizes the likelihood of dissociation. You'll also want to keep an eye on whether they can stay present with you. If they're getting overwhelmed or losing their sense of being in the session, pause and return to preparation. The wording you choose is one adaptation, and you'll still need to assess how your client responds.
Organizing potential targets linked to negative beliefs
Once you've identified several memories, you'll need to organize them around your client's current problems and the negative beliefs that connect them. Recording those connections gives you a clearer basis for deciding which memories may belong together and what you still need to explore during history taking.
Use the EMDR Target Selection: Clinician Handout to organize the potential targets before moving into sequencing. The worksheet includes the negative-beliefs approach and floatback, helping you bring your client's symptoms, beliefs, and associated experiences into a working target list.
→ EMDR Target Selection: Clinician Handout
When the Negative Cognition Gives You Limited Information
Sometimes a negative belief is so broad that it doesn't give you much direction. A client might say, “I am worthless,” about almost everything in their history. In that situation, I'd want to get more specific about the problem we're working on. When did they last feel that way, what was happening, and what did they notice in their body?
You'll also have clients who can tell you what they believe intellectually, but the words don't seem to connect with what they're experiencing as they bring up the memory. Check with them about whether the wording fits. You can also ask about the image, feelings, and physical sensations to see what else is available. There may be several reasons they're having difficulty connecting, so I wouldn't assume that the wording is the only issue.
Sometimes another belief comes up as you're talking through the experience. That's information you can use, and you don't have to make your client stay with the first statement they gave you. Ask which belief fits what they're noticing now and whether the other theme needs to be noted for later.
If I find that we're spending a lot of time trying to get the negative cognition and it's becoming frustrating, I may move to an affect scan. Some clients can describe the feelings and physical sensations much more easily than they can identify a belief. You can use that information to explore earlier experiences, or use a timeline to look at when the symptoms started and when they became worse.
If your client is having difficulty identifying a negative cognition, I recommend moving to an affect scan. Start with a recent or representative experience, ask what emotions and physical sensations they notice, and invite them to scan back to an earlier time they felt that way. This gives you a way to continue identifying possible targets using the information your client can access. Timelines and Floatback in EMDR Target Selection walks through these approaches and how you can use them during history taking.
To compare the available methods, use the free EMDR Target Selection Approaches Infographic. It provides a quick reference as you decide how to continue identifying targets with your client.
→ Free EMDR Target Selection Approaches Infographic
Moving From Belief-Linked Targets to Sequencing
Once you have the possible targets, you and your client can start discussing the order. This is where I'd look at the symptoms they're most concerned about, what you've learned about the memories, and how prepared they are for processing. Having a similar negative cognition across the targets helps with organizing them, but you still have sequencing decisions to make.
There are several ways to approach that. With the belief-focused method in the Two Method Approach, you begin with the memory your client feels proves the core belief the most. With symptom-informed planning, you're looking at the history of the symptom and the experiences connected with it (de Jongh et al., 2010; Leeds, 2016). You'll notice that these approaches overlap in some ways, but they can lead you to different starting points.
For me, I often use symptom-informed sequencing and look at the earliest memory, the worst or a representative memory, the most recent, and other experiences that still hold disturbance. But sometimes the earliest memory is too intense for your client, and we need to discuss another starting point or spend more time on preparation. If you're choosing a less disturbing memory, let your client know that processing may still connect with earlier or more difficult experiences.
As you complete targets, go back and check the remaining memories with your client. Generalization can happen, so a memory that was very disturbing when you made the plan may now have much less charge. You'll also want them to pay attention to what's activating them between sessions. That helps you decide what still needs attention in the past, with present triggers, and in future templates (Shapiro, 2018).
Once you've organized your client's potential targets, the next step is to decide where to begin and how to sequence the work. The blog EMDR Target Selection vs. Target Sequencing explains how these decisions differ and how each contributes to treatment planning.
To move from your target list into a sequencing plan, use the EMDR Target Sequencing: Clinician Guide. The guide helps you organize treatment priorities while considering your client's symptoms, readiness, and the relationships among the identified memories.
→ EMDR Target Sequencing: Clinician Guide
Continuing Education in EMDR Treatment Planning
A negative cognition can be useful at several points in treatment planning. You may use it to identify memories, notice a theme across experiences, or help decide which target-selection approach fits your client. You'll then bring that information into the broader sequencing discussion.
In the CE EMDR Treatment Planning: Target Selection and Sequencing, I walk through several approaches and use clinical examples to show how you might apply them. The course is self-paced, provides 2 CE credits, and is offered by Cannon Psychology, an APA-Approved Sponsor of continuing education for psychologists. It is also approved by EMDRIA for 2 Credits. It's meant to supplement formal EMDR training and consultation.
→ EMDR Treatment Planning: Target Selection and Sequencing CE
The EMDR Training & Treatment Hub brings together the related articles, clinician tools, and continuing education. You can use it to continue with treatment planning or review preparation and readiness as you think through the next step with your client.
→ EMDR Training & Treatment Hub
Conclusion
When the same negative belief keeps coming up, spend some time looking at it with your client during history taking. Ask which experiences seem to support it, what they notice in their body when they say it, and when they remember feeling that way before. You may begin to see connections between the problem that brought them into treatment and experiences from different points in their life.
As you gather those memories, pay attention to whether the beliefs fit within a similar domain. Your client may use different words that reflect the same sense of responsibility, or you may discover that some experiences are more about safety or defectiveness. Discuss those differences with your client. Their explanation can help you decide which memories may belong together and which themes need to be explored separately.
If your client has difficulty identifying a negative cognition, I recommend moving to an affect scan. Start with a recent or representative experience and use the emotions and physical sensations they can identify to explore earlier experiences. A timeline can also help you understand when the problem began and what was happening when the symptoms became worse. You can return to the negative belief as you learn more about the history.
Once you've identified possible targets, review them with your client and consider how they fit with the symptoms they want help with and their readiness for processing. Keep checking the plan as treatment continues. Some memories may become less disturbing after another target has been processed, while other experiences may still need attention. What you learn during history taking gives you a starting point, and your client's responses help you decide how to proceed.
Research References
de Jongh, A., ten Broeke, E., & Meijer, S. (2010). Two method approach: A case conceptualization model in the context of EMDR. Journal of EMDR Practice and Research, 4(1), 12–21. https://doi.org/10.1891/1933-3196.4.1.12
Leeds, A. M. (2016). A guide to the standard EMDR therapy protocols for clinicians, supervisors, and consultants (2nd ed.). Springer Publishing Company.
Shapiro, F. (2018). Eye movement desensitization and reprocessing (EMDR) therapy: Basic principles, protocols, and procedures (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.